... Nice.
I really liked this story, KJ. When you said that you were trying to make Katherine kind of childish and adult-like at the same time, I was thinking,
If she pulls that off, I'll be impressed.
Well. I'm impressed. You have the sentences where there were it showed that she was kind of... numbly accepting, I guess you'd call it... like an adult. For example, when she was talking about how she was an embarrassing and appalling secret to Elisa and Father; people who were more childish would try to find another explanation for the way that those two acted around her. Then you had the sentences where she looked a bit more like a kid; for example, right at the end, when she was thinking that she and Knight could actually be friends. The way that you made it seem like the idea was a bit shocking to her, and how you made it seem like she was a little shy and nervous about the thought, made her seem like a little girl. I really liked the combination of child-ness and adult-ness. It made Katherine seem very unique.
I thoguht that the grammar in your writing was quite perfect overall. There was just this one sentence that confused me:
But that day Elisa had had some friends over, and seeing all of them laugh and joke he struck something in me I’d tried to shove away.
I'm sorry, but I don't understand why the word 'he' is in that sentence. Maybe I'm just reading the sentence too quickly or looking at it from the wrong way, but would you mind just clearing that question up for me?
Also, I think that angels-symphony was right when she said that you used the word 'Father' one or two many times in the first few paragraphs. I didn't think that it made
him seem stiff, however; I thought that it made your writing seem a bit too formal. Sorry.
There was this sentence that I found a little off, as well:
My sister, who was usually gone all the time during the day and after school, suddenly was around.
There was nothing grammatically wrong with this sentence, or anything off about the way that you explained it; I'm just used to seeing a sentence like that more like, 'My sister,...,
was suddenly around.' I'm kind of used to seeing the 'was' before the adjective... if that's what 'suddenly' is... I'm not really good at separating my verbs and adverbs and adjectives and stuff. It's probably just because your writing style is different that I'm used to- and, actually, better- but I just thought that I ought to mention it. The fact that I'm resorting to little perfectionist things like that really shows how few things that I can find wrong with 'House of Shadows'... once again, I'm impressed.
Oh, yeah. I was able to figure out who the characters were- Elisa is the sister, Katherine is the main character, Knight is the boy- but I think that if someone read through the story too quickly, or wasn't looking closely enough, they would be confused... as those two reviews before mine proved. You just might want to mention their names once or twice more.
I'll be really excited to read more of this. I really enjoy the idea, and I like the raw way that you state stuff. Please shoot me a PM when you post up the next part, and keep writing!