Kylan
how superior. Master of the Forum

 Gender:  Age: 16 Joined: 21 Apr 2007 Posts: 1092 Reviews: 270 Country: USA 372 Points
|
Posted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 7:09 pm Post subject: Swapping Your Blood with Formaldehyde (Part 3 and 4) |
|
|
And she's got red lipstick and a bright pair of shoes
and she's got knee high socks, what to cover a bruise
-Andrew Bird, "Fake Palindromes"
Part 3; [028. Face]
Lena was lying on the hospital bed and tracing the arthritic cracks that fingered their way across the ceiling like tributaries on a map. The ceiling itself was sick and jaundiced looking, as if it had received one too many bouquets of cigarette smoke.
It groaned quietly.
There was a second floor above her and the footsteps of the doctors and nurses and patients walking on it created modest thunderstorms for her enjoyment. She thought it sounded like the sky was going to collapse, or that a thousand drunken giants with broken legs were waltzing to the music of gurney rattles and hushed mortuary voices.
Inside, Lena was dead.
And the ring on her finger weighed as much as an electric trolley.
Over and over, she went over the scene in her mind, dissecting it, trying to locate the cause of Matthew's outburst. She replayed every movement, every expression on his face like a silent picture reel. He was drunk. He was angry. He was out of a job. But, hell, who wasn't these days? Who wasn't sitting at the dining room table with a drink in one hand and an unemployment check in the other? It was as if all of the parts of the equation had been thrown in a centrifuge like a test tube of blood and mixed into jigsaw puzzle pieces. She wished that she could talk to him. She wished she could apologize, for whatever she had done.
But he was gone.
And it didn't look like he was ever coming back.
Lena clenched her jaw shut and gasped a little, her vision suddenly warped and water-damaged by angry, helpless tears. Her heart was throbbing in her ears, as if someone was cranking at her ear drum like an air raid alarm.
To hold and to cherish.
She bit her lip and touched the gauze mummifying her head like a monarch butterfly pupa and the bandage draped over her right eye. She felt broken. She felt violate and confused. Why in God's name would he do something like that, sober or otherwise? What about love? What about holding and cherishing, for God's sake? Lena pictured his face again as he clutched her hair like a mound of shoelaces before thrusting her head into the plaster again. She magnified his eyes – little stained-glass soul windows, like blacked-out bar windows. She searched for a trace of the old Matthew. She searched for a trace of the man at the altar.
Instead, Lena found apathy and selfishness.
You know, doll? Some people are real bastards.
She felt her lips crumpling and her eyes cementing.
Alright.
I'll give that one to you.
Around her, the hospital made library-volume whispers. Whispers that spoke of lineaments and skin-colored gauze and feverish last words. Her bruises were like liver spots.
Part 4; 042. Lost
At the moment, the handgun was looking awfully appealing.
It looked good enough to slip between her lips like some kind of Cuban cigar, savor the oil, and massage the trigger. Lena imagined it would taste like the smells that had radiated from that French café she and Matthew had visited on their honeymoon in Tahiti. Smells that could only come from a vivisected honeybee hive or from a steaming mountain of bread dough. It would taste like celestial and pearl-studded gates laced with chocolate and little streamers of coffee.
It would taste like Death.
Who would rest its hand on her shoulder, lift her chin with its finger, and grin.
It would like a doll-sized Catrina, with hollow eight-ball eye-sockets and a beautiful exposé of opaline teeth.
Lena was sitting in front of a cracked mirror. The same mirror, in fact, that her husband Matthew had thrown a chair at three months before. Vaguely, she supposed that it was possible that Death was already with her. She supposed it was possible that Death was the face in the mirror. Her skin was wrapped around her skull like cellophane, her hair hung in blackberry vine tangles around her face, and she was about to smoke a gun.
She smiled at the reflection.
Got a light?
Death just smiled back, and its eyes were smoldering sulfur matchsticks.
Lena looked at the gun dispassionately. There was no appeal or attractiveness to the image of a dining room wall graffitied with blood and little bits of silent screams, or the image of a broken woman withering on a floor like a crushed bridal flower mashed into the aisle. It was an ugly picture. It was a painting for the surrealists and their dreamscape pastels.
Real beauty rested on cathedral altars and in the crepe-paper hands of priests whose heads looked like polished jewels nestled inside ecclesiastic cowls. Beauty was in whispered words spoken in consummate beds. Beauty was in the way lovers held hands as they walked down park avenues or mushed sand through their toes on sun-stained beaches.
It was in the tears of a sky and a mother.
It was in the bird-wing flutter of a bridal veil.
It was in rings that acted as all-natural preservatives.
Lena smiled once more into the mirror. Again, it was not her own face that stared back at her. It was Death, with features so white that it someone had dipped it in bleach. Or ripped the mother-of-pearl off grand piano keys and pasted it to this rotting skull like tongue depressors.
She wasn't getting her marriage back.
She wasn't getting Matthew back.
And Death had a face like a starving child.
Breathing heavily, Lena looked back down at the gun and wondered if Matthew had ever smoked a Cuban cigar. |
_________________ "'At's the shtuff! Give the friggin' world back to the friggin' people!"
~ Kurt Vonnegut
Got YWS? |
|
Suzanne
won NaNoWriMo! Writer of Legend

 Gender:  Age: 18 Joined: 21 Sep 2006 Posts: 7088 Reviews: 1754 Country: Riverbluff, MO 1160 Points
|
Posted: Sun Jun 15, 2008 4:14 am Post subject: |
|
|
Mmm. Do I get cookies/love for being the first one here, yet again?
| Quote: |
| Lena was lying on the hospital bed and tracing the arthritic cracks that fingered their way across the ceiling like tributaries on a map. |
Your verbs are messy here. you start with "was lying" - passive again, go to "lied". In the next phrase you say "tracing" which relies on the "was" in the previous phrase. That's fine, but it isn't as pretty as you want it. Think about it, you're in the past tense - so why do you have an -ing verb there? "Lena lied on the hospital bed and traced..." It's more on going, more now.
| Quote: |
| The ceiling itself was sick and jaundiced looking, as if it had received one too many bouquets of cigarette smoke. |
"Sick" and "jaundiced-looking" (Yes, hyphenate it) are the same thing. Choose the stronger one, jaundiced-looking. "Bouquets of cigarette smoke", as beautiful as it is, is too mixed for me. I can't get the idea down in my head - are we talking about smoke (a gas) or flowers? of course I know what is being said, and I understand it, but it's too strange. You want to pick something that makes sense with smoke - flowers just don't.
| Quote: |
| It groaned quietly. |
. . . The ceiling groaned? Oh my.
| Quote: |
There was a second floor above her and the footsteps of the doctors and nurses and patients doctors, nurses, and patients walking on it created modest thunderstorms for her enjoyment. |
I didn't like the "it' there, so I cut it... the other part just sounds better how I set it... up to you?
| Quote: |
| Inside, Lena was dead. |
I don't like this. I would prefer a paragraph about how she feels - that says, in the end, that she feels dead. Of course, without directly saying it. Your a poet - do it.
| Quote: |
Over and over, she went over through the scene in her mind, dissecting it, trying to locate the cause of Matthew's outburst. |
Redundancy with "over".
| Quote: |
| Who wasn't sitting at the dining room table with a drink in one hand and an unemployment check in the other? |
1. I've mentioned it before, but, Prohibition and the Temperance Movement.
2. Unemployment checks: "Wisconsin originated the idea of Unemployment insurance in the US in 1932." So, these didn't exist at this time period. I didn't think so, but I did the research (easily) just in case. A lot of the things we have in our system now that help unemployed works came because of the Great Depression. They weren't in existence during. But I won't lecture, you can read for yourself.
| Quote: |
| Over and over, she went over the scene in her mind, dissecting it, trying to locate the cause of Matthew's outburst. She replayed every movement, every expression on his face like a silent picture reel. He was drunk. He was angry. He was out of a job. But, hell, who wasn't these days? Who wasn't sitting at the dining room table with a drink in one hand and an unemployment check in the other? It was as if all of the parts of the equation had been thrown in a centrifuge like a test tube of blood and mixed into jigsaw puzzle pieces. She wished that she could talk to him. She wished she could apologize, for whatever she had done. |
Euh. I don't know. So, you have internal monologue. A bit of me says, "Why do I care about Lena?" another part of me says, don't tell me why he did it. You should have provided enough reason in the previous section so that Lena didn't have to babble about it and bore me. If you had done it properly in the first place (not to say you did it horribly, but, you know) you wouldn't need this paragraph, and it fact it would be redundant. I really don't like it. But I'm fussy.
| Quote: |
But he was gone.
And It didn't look like he was ever coming back. |
| Quote: |
| Her heart was throbbing in her ears, as if someone was cranking at her ear drum like an air raid alarm. |
OK, back off of the imagery button, kiddo. You're overwhelming your reader. You don't need to drown us - just let us swim. "throbbing in her ears" is good enough - what you have else is too much, too strong. I just feel overwhelmed, and your metaphors only confuse me and don't help me envision anything.
| Quote: |
| She bit her lip and touched the gauze mummifying her head like a monarch butterfly pupa and the bandage draped over her right eye. |
I can't figure out if you are trying to hard, or you're just... lost. This is too confusing. It looks like you're trying to hard - either to be artful, or to make your reader feel. Either way, you're failing at both. A metaphor should be seemless in the text... it should make sense... it shouldn't overwhelm me. You use too many things. Mummifying, monarch butterfly pupa - does the specification of the butterfly matter? Mummy and Butterfly don't, generally go together - cocoon does. It's too overwhelming, too much, and it ends up making no sense what so ever and hurts to read. I love metaphors - you can probably notice I use them like crazy. But they have to make sense, and they can't be too... grand. Er, the best way I can explain this is in the space of words. Think of a poem. Everyone word you use has to be he best word. Using two words to describe something, rather than five, is always good. Be slim - otherwise you loose your reader. Don't take so much space when writing a metaphor. You over think, over work. Simplify. You can still be apt and beautiful when you have less words - and more than anything, you will make sense.
I'm going to rant now before I forget anything; now that I'm at the end of three.
Alright, so, we have Lena. My big problem with her is I don't care about her at all. But I've found more. It's more flaws in Matt, and in general, just flaws in their whole set up. I'll try not to confuse you, or myself, while explaining this.
I don't care about Lena. I don't know how you can fix this, but I do not care about her whatsoever and if I didn't love you, I wouldn't read this. Really, I wouldn't. It does not matter how detailed your plot is, how beautiful your language is, or how amazing your writing is - if your characters are not interesting, if I cannot connect to them, if I cannot relate, feel sympathy for, care about, then I don't care about and will not want to read your story. I think, and I might be wrong, that this is a bigger problem you have with your writing. You're a great writer - no doubt - but your characters are props to your plot. And.. some writers agree, plot before characters. But you still need the balance. You only give us characters to do what you want, you do not give us full, blooded people that we can love and care for. I can't see them standing in the real world. I don't know how they would react in a given situation. I don't know if this is a lack of development on your part, or the way you're writing it - but it's bothersome. It's a real flaw, and I hate to dig my nails right into, but I have to.
Now, to Matt. The problem comes with Lena thinking about him.
| Quote: |
| She searched for a trace of the old Matthew. |
This is both about Lena and about Matt. I don't know what old Matt was like. I have no idea. I can't even begin to guess because, honestly, I don't know who he is now. This is a problem for his development, because if I don't know there is a change, as a reader, then really... it kind of failed. I don't know what he was like before... so really, what we have now [whatever that is] doesn't seem so strange. I feel no contrast - you gave no example as to what he was before hand.
Additionally, you gave no forewarning to what he would become. I spoke of this before, but I can't help but say it again. You have to show us he is capable of this. People don't just get violent one evening - they have a tendency towards violence, either hidden, or curbed. This isn't always a real life thing, but it needs to be in your characters. If I don't see, early on, that your character has the possibility of going crazy-angry, then when he does, I can't believe it. You have hunted, shot, and killed my suspension of belief.
This affects Lena because I don't know what she's missing. I don't know what she had for Matt, I don't know why she loved him. Heck, I don't know why they got married, why he loved her, what they had in the marriage. It's important to them as people, why they got married, how they felt about each other, and how they feel now. You can't continue to tell me about them, lead me through their lives, if I don't know more about them, and how they got here. It's all about character development. Anyway, if I don't know what Matt was like, and what she's missing, I can't sympathize with her at all. Heck, it could have been her stupidity that got her into an abusive relationship - not much sympathy there, eh? Or maybe she was deceived as to who he truly was - but we don't know.
From all this babble, you can pull one thing: you need to develop your characters. Even for short stories. If your characters are not developed, they will not feel alive, and no matter what your plot, the story will fall apart.
| Quote: |
It looked good enough to slip between her lips like some kind of Cuban cigar, savor the oil, and massage the trigger. Lena imagined it would taste like the smells that had radiated from that French café she and Matthew had visited on their honeymoon in Tahiti. Smells that could only come from a vivisected honeybee hive or from a steaming mountain of bread dough. It would taste like celestial and pearl-studded gates laced with chocolate and little streamers of coffee. |
The metaphor at the beginning - the first sentence - beautiful. See, you don't go over the top always! The last sentence I cut? Unnecessary. It's just a poor retelling of what was in the previous sentence. You only need to say something once - once, and to your best abbility.
| Quote: |
It would taste like Death.
Who would rest its hand on her shoulder, lift her chin with its finger, and grin.
It would like a doll-sized Catrina, with hollow eight-ball eye-sockets and a beautiful exposé of opaline teeth. |
I love this first line here. Beautiful. The second line? I got confused. I had to reread it. I was still confused. The second line? Much more confusion. Probably because I don't know what on earth you mean by Catrina. Don't rely on things so specific as that, that your reader may not know. Er, because you just lost me entirely, not from the specifics, but... Just, lost. Mostly the second sentence. Don't get me wrong, I know what you are saying. I understand it, but it's the syntax, it's how you are saying it, it's the fact that it does not make sense on first read, that "it" is too vague.
| Quote: |
Lena was sitting sat in front of a cracked mirror. |
| Quote: |
Vaguely, She supposed that it was possible that Death was already with her. |
| Quote: |
| Lena looked at the gun dispassionately |
Please, No. No no no no no. No crazy, meaningless, lazy -ly adjectives. You're a writer. You can do better than that.
| Quote: |
| There was no appeal or attractiveness to the image of a dining room wall graffitied with blood and little bits of silent screams, or the image of a broken woman withering on a floor like a crushed bridal flower mashed into the aisle. |
I think graffiti is too period to use here - I think of spray paint on the side of highways. It just doesn't fit here. But, I will say, the metaphor linked to wedding is good.
| Quote: |
| ...the crepe-paper hands of priests whose heads looked like polished jewels nestled inside ecclesiastic cowls. |
You're giving me too much again. Sure, on one hand, you're being vivid - but to what end? What does this detail say about Lena?
| Quote: |
| with features so white that it someone had dipped it in bleach. |
Missing words?
| Quote: |
| Or ripped the mother-of-pearl off grand piano keys and pasted it to this rotting skull like tongue depressors. |
Hm... what?
I'll give you that the last line is beautiful.
Otherwise, I'm not giving you much of anything. So... should I care that Lena is going to kill herself?
You give us no reason why she would do this. Of course! you say, pointing to the obvious, it makes sense! Ah, but why would she do it? Why is Lena the type of person to turn to suicide? Does she blame herself? Does she see nothing better in life? Does she have a relative who killed themselves, so it now seems reasonable? You may think she has reason - but if she doesn't have the reason inside of herself, as a person capable and willing to do something like this, then she shouldn't be trying it. It seems fake, planted, staged - I can't believe it what so ever, and so again, I don't care, because she seems like a puppet, doing what you want her to do - not doing what I am fully certain Lena would do. What would she do? I don't know - I know nothing about her.
Then she seems to switch, some how, I'm not sure, out of it. In fact I'm not even sure she switched out of it, but that seemed to be what you were suggesting. What, too, caused this? Because I don't know her as a person, it makes no sense, and I cannot comprehend her. It's all the same blah blah blah, I said above, only about different things.
The rhetorical "It was" "it was" "it was" and "she wasn't" look slightly pretty - but they don't do much for me. I don't feel they have the power, the shock they should. It's hard to use repetition to create something strong; try reading speeches and studying rhetoric. That's the only way to do it. You can repeat anything, but if you don't have the power, the strength in what you are saying, then the parallelism does nothing.
Final tip of the night: You are not a puppet master; you are a writer. You give birth to characters; you do not use props on a stage.
As always, darling! PM me with questions or comments, and feel free to discuss! Please realize I hate ripping into you. I just hope that you agree, or at least somewhat agree, and that I'm not entirely being silly and wrong. I'd feel so terrible. I do it because I love you! ^_~ |
_________________ I demand
you put my heart back in my hand,
and wipe it clean from the mess you made of me. |
|