Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Firefox 3

News:  

NaNoWriMo

YWS Birthday Smash!
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
Judgement day: chapter 1 (part 1)
Judgement day: chapter 1 (part 1)

by Nighty Night Gobbo in Other Fiction
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction

This thread was created on June 12, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us

Related Items
Possible Related Items Follow:
Bubbling, chapter 1
Bubbling, chapter 2
Bubbling, chapter 3
Bubbling, chapter 4
Bubbling, chapter 5
Bubbling, chapter 6
Bubbling, chapter 7
Bubbling, chapter 8

Bubbling, chapter 9

Topic ID: 31517
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Demeter   View This User's Portfolio
is dying to find her own Munkustrap.
Speaker of the Forum

265
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 15
Joined: 02 May 2008
Posts: 886
Reviews: 265
Country: Finland – the noble land of polar bears and Santa Claus
757 Points

PostPosted: Thu Jun 12, 2008 7:27 pm    Post subject: Bubbling, chapter 9 Reply with quote

Mom has made bangers and mash. Reckon Cinnamon's first "city meal" must be something else than burgers or barbie.

Mom looks still annoyed, but that's totally in vain, I tell you. I haven't done anything but tried to tell her everything's fine and that I don't boycott Cinnamon anymore.

"I thought you would like this, sweetie", Mom coos to Cinnamon, who nods politely.

"Reckon, Mrs Chevrol... Ebony."

"Hey Mom. That's meat."

"'Course it is. There's no such thing as bangers without meat, is there?"

"I'm a vegetarian. That means I don't eat meat. Remember?" What's wrong with her?

"Give it away, Satin. You have eaten meat before."

"Yeah, but that was before I realized that a piece of Piglet on a plate is something pretty disgusting."

Mom doesn't even bother to answer.

Cinnamon puts her knife down on the plate.

"Satin. I know that you have principles, and I truly appeciate your opinion."

"Belt up, then."

"Satin!" Mom frowns to me from the other side of the table. I grimace to her.

"The idea is", Cinnamon goes on, "– that the animals for slaughter –"

"Don't say that!"

Reckon she said that just for my bad.

"– the animals for slaughter are grown for people to eat them. They don't just decide that 'Oh jolly, let's go and have little Fluffy the lamb killed'. They're grown for it. And besides, even though you'd refuse to eat and starve instead, you can't do anything – the hind leg of dear Honeybun is still there, lying on your plate. I know it sounds nasty, but that's how it goes. The agroindustry won't be stopped because of some random girl in some random place. Eat or don't, but you can't avoid it forever. You have to eat all-around, so –"

"Yeah, sure, I know." I've listened to her with my mouth wide open – I must have looked like a dill. "Our teacher of health studies tells us those same things every year. Reckon she has dementia or something."

Mom makes a weird noise.

"Don't you talk that way about Mrs Hamdram, young lady", she says. "You know she's been my good mate..."

"Yeah. Since college. But she's still an old –"

"Sorry to interrupt your... interesting conversation", Cinnamon cuts me off. "Satin, I admire your try to change the topic, but I won't let you away with it. Just eat the meat and stop whinging. Or eat some bread, then."

"But it's gross." I feel a little taken back by Cinnamon's shut-up-and-listen attitude.

She sighs, looking suddenly zonked.

"Nothing can be. You may not like it, but it still isn't gross. Your mother and I like it, so it can't be gross. As long as someone likes something, it just can't be gross." She says all this very serenely, but her speech makes me feel like a five-year-old.

"That's true!" Mom says excitedly. "What luck to have so smart relatives, right, Satin?"

Cinnamon clearly tries to look innocent when I glance at her, but then she looks up and grins mischievously.

I cry out and fill my mouth with a big bite of banger. After swallowing, I start to chew an enourmous piece of toast.

Cinnamon keeps staring at the plate, but even a stupid one could see this little annoying flash of smile on her face. No matter how hard I resist, though – the joy escapes from Cinnamon's lips to mine. I try to hide it with the toast, but Cinnamon's grin just widens.

Mom watches one more time – obviously ensuring – me eating her bangers, and forms the words "Thanks" with her mouth.

No hoper.

"Cinnamon, you're weird."

"I know. So are you. But at least now you have buttered your bread."

Ha ha ha. A nice little flashback of my morning stupidity waves in front of my eyes. Mom scowls, not getting it.

"Just a little inside joke", I clarify quickly.

"So you're having secrets already? How fun!" When she stands up to fill the water can, I stick two fingers inside my mouth to show how yuckily she spoke. Cinnamon gives an unsure smile, not deciding whether it's approriate to laugh behind someone else's mother's back. It's funny. Even though I'd speak my Mom down to some of my friends, I'd go bonkers if the friend actually agreed with me. Cinnamon seems to think the same.

"Your middle name is Elizabeth, right?" she says suddenly.

"Yeah. Because of that lipstick." I glance quickly at Mom to see how she reacts, but she doesn't seem to notice.

"Then your initials are S. E. C."

"So...?" She's totally beating around the bush.

"Sec means 'dry'. In French", Cinnamon announces and keeps on eating.

"And?"

"Nothing. I finished."

I'm having a hard time deciding whether this was a poor try to start a conversation or is Cinnamon just proving her ability to sink under the surface whenever and wherever.

I think I'll go with the latter.


_________________
While you were reading my signature, I took your wallet.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Eimear   View This User's Portfolio
It ain't me, babe
Speaker of the Forum

314
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 17
Joined: 26 Jan 2008
Posts: 646
Reviews: 314
Country: In a Dickens novel
300 Points

PostPosted: Sat Jun 14, 2008 5:53 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Quote:
Mom has made bangers and mash. Reckon Cinnamon's first "city meal" must be something else than burgers or barbie. Aren't Bangers and Mash a traditional meal from England?

Mom looks still annoyed, but that's totally in vain, I tell you. I haven't done anything but tried to tell her everything's fine and that I don't boycott Cinnamon anymore.

"I thought you would like this, sweetie", Mom coos to Cinnamon, who nods politely.

"Reckon, Mrs Chevrol... Ebony." 'Reckon' sounds wierd here

"Hey Mom. That's meat."

"'Course it is. There's no such thing as bangers without meat, is there?"

"I'm a vegetarian. That means I don't eat meat. Remember?" What's wrong with her?

"Give it away, Satin. You have eaten meat before." Do you mean, "Give it up, Satin?"

"Yeah, but that was before I realized that a piece of Piglet on a plate is something pretty disgusting."

Mom doesn't even bother to answer.

Cinnamon puts her knife down on the plate.

"Satin. I know that you have principles, and I truly appeciate your opinion."

"Belt up, then." Haha. Funny stuff.

"Satin!" Mom frowns to me from the other side of the table. I grimace to her.

"The idea is", Cinnamon goes on, "– that the animals for slaughter –"

"Don't say that!"

Reckon she said that just for my bad.

"– the animals for slaughter are grown for people to eat them. They don't just decide that 'Oh jolly, let's go and have little Fluffy the lamb killed'. They're grown for it. And besides, even though you'd refuse to eat and starve instead, you can't do anything – the hind leg of dear Honeybun is still there, lying on your plate. I know it sounds nasty, but that's how it goes. The agroindustry won't be stopped because of some random girl in some random place. Eat or don't, but you can't avoid it forever. You have to eat all-around, so –"

"Yeah, sure, I know." I've listened to her with my mouth wide open – I must have looked like a dill. "Our teacher of health studies tells us those same things every year. Reckon she has dementia or something."

Mom makes a weird noise.

"Don't you talk that way about Mrs Hamdram, young lady", she says. "You know she's been my good mate..." Mate? There's some strange word choices in here, 'mate' I associate with England and Ireland.

"Yeah. Since college. But she's still an old –"

"Sorry to interrupt your... interesting conversation", Cinnamon cuts me off. "Satin, I admire your try to change the topic, but I won't let you away with it. Just eat the meat and stop whinging. Or eat some bread, then."

"But it's gross." I feel a little taken back by Cinnamon's shut-up-and-listen attitude.

She sighs, looking suddenly zonked.

"Nothing can be. You may not like it, but it still isn't gross. Your mother and I like it, so it can't be gross. As long as someone likes something, it just can't be gross." She says all this very serenely, but her speech makes me feel like a five-year-old.

"That's true!" Mom says excitedly. "What luck to have so smart relatives, right, Satin?"

Cinnamon clearly tries to look innocent when I glance at her, but then she looks up and grins mischievously.

I cry out and fill my mouth with a big bite of banger. After swallowing, I start to chew an enourmous piece of toast.

Cinnamon keeps staring at the plate, but even a stupid one could see this little annoying flash of smile on her face. No matter how hard I resist, though – the joy escapes from Cinnamon's lips to mine. I try to hide it with the toast, but Cinnamon's grin just widens.

Mom watches one more time – obviously ensuring – me eating her bangers, and forms the words "Thanks" with her mouth.

No hoper.

"Cinnamon, you're weird."

"I know. So are you. But at least now you have buttered your bread."

Ha ha ha. A nice little flashback of my morning stupidity waves in front of my eyes. Mom scowls, not getting it.

"Just a little inside joke", I clarify quickly.

"So you're having secrets already? How fun!" When she stands up to fill the water can, I stick two fingers inside my mouth to show how yuckily she spoke. Cinnamon gives an unsure smile, not deciding whether it's approriate to laugh behind someone else's mother's back. It's funny. Even though I'd speak my Mom down to some of my friends, I'd go bonkers if the friend actually agreed with me. Cinnamon seems to think the same.

"Your middle name is Elizabeth, right?" she says suddenly.

"Yeah. Because of that lipstick." I glance quickly at Mom to see how she reacts, but she doesn't seem to notice.

"Then your initials are S. E. C."

"So...?" She's totally beating around the bush.

"Sec means 'dry'. In French", Cinnamon announces and keeps on eating.

"And?"

"Nothing. I finished."


This chapter, I'm not going to lie, is a little random. I think the term 'Murder your Darlings' is an appropriate piece of advice here. Although I did find this funny in places, I'm still struggling to see a solid plot emerging. There's no suspense, hints of conflict, and the dialogue goes on for a while. Every single time someone opens their mouth in your writing you need to stop and think 'Does this represent the character's personality and move the plot along or is it just talk to fill the space?'

However, now for the positives- your writing is really improving. It seems like you've finally settled into your own unique voice and it's something of a joy to read. I like the characters and they are beginning to feel real. So great job!

Please remember when I comment on your work I'm not telling you that your writing is bad- I'm just trying to show you what a reader would be thinking when reading it. They're a perceptive bunch, are readers. Even the ones that don't write. Just remember, plan ahead. The reader will sense unease in your writing like a dog smells fear.

Best wishes,

Eimear

_________________
We are all in the gutter, but some of us are looking at the stars.

-Oscar Wilde-
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message MSN Messenger
pegasi_quill   View This User's Portfolio
Senior Writer

40
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 02 May 2008
Posts: 147
Reviews: 40
Country: Poland
300 Points

PostPosted: Mon Jun 23, 2008 2:38 pm    Post subject: Re: Bubbling, chapter 9 Reply with quote

Demeter wrote:
Mom has made bangers and mash. Reckon Cinnamon's first "city meal" must be something else than burgers or barbie.

Mom looks still annoyed, but that's totally in vain, I can tell you. I haven't done anything but tried try to tell her everything's fine and that I don't boycott Cinnamon anymore.

"I thought you would like this, sweetie", Mom coos to Cinnamon, who nods politely.

"Reckon, Mrs Chevrol... Ebony." ...sorry, I don't really understand her answer. "reckon"?

"Hey Mom. That's meat."

"'Course it is. There's no such thing as bangers without meat, is there?"

"I'm a vegetarian. That means I don't eat meat. Remember?" What's wrong with her?

"Give it away, Satin. You have eaten meat before."

"Yeah, but that was before I realized that a piece of Piglet on a plate is something pretty disgusting."

Mom doesn't even bother to answer.

Cinnamon puts her knife down on the plate.

"Satin. I know that you have principles, and I truly appeciate your opinion."

"Belt up, then."

"Satin!" Mom frowns to me from the other side of the table. I grimace to at her.

"The idea is", Cinnamon goes on, "– that the animals for slaughter –"

"Don't say that!"

Reckon she said that just for my bad. "my bad" is misfitting, reconsider word choice here

"– the animals for slaughter are grown for people to eat them. They don't just decide that 'Oh jolly, let's go and have little Fluffy the lamb killed'. They're grown for it. And besides, even though you'd refuse to eat and starve instead, you can't do anything – the hind leg of dear Honeybun is still there, lying on your plate. I know it sounds nasty, but that's how it goes. The agroindustry won't be stopped because of some random girl in some random place. Eat or don't, but you can't avoid it forever. You have to eat all-around, so –"

"Yeah, sure, I know." I've listened to her with my mouth wide open – I must have looked like a dill. "Our teacher of health studies tells us those same things every year. Reckon she has dementia or something."

Mom makes a weird noise.

"Don't you talk that way about Mrs Hamdram, young lady", she says. "You know she's been my good mate..." Mate? Would a woman really say that about a school teacher who happens to be her freind? Again, I think it sounds a bit strange.

"Yeah. Since college. But she's still an old –"

"Sorry to interrupt your... interesting conversation", Cinnamon cuts me off. "Satin, I admire your try to change the topic, but I won't let you away with it. Just eat the meat and stop whinging. Or eat some bread, then."

"But it's gross." I feel a little taken back by Cinnamon's shut-up-and-listen attitude. A little taken aback? I'd have thought Stain would have lost it by now, and seen Cinnamon's behaviour as an arrogant, know-it-all new girl. You have made Cinnamon sound like that, you know

She sighs, looking suddenly zonked.

"Nothing can be. You may not like it, but it still isn't gross. Your mother and I like it, so it can't be gross. As long as someone likes something, it just can't be gross." She says all this very serenely, but her speech makes me feel like a five-year-old.

"That's true!" Mom says excitedly. "What luck to have so such smart relatives, right, Satin?"

Cinnamon clearly tries to look innocent when I glance at her, but then she looks up and grins mischievously.

I cry out and fill my mouth with a big bite of banger. After swallowing, I start to chew an enourmous piece of toast.

Cinnamon keeps staring at the plate, but even a stupid one could see this little annoying flash of smile on her face. No matter how hard I resist, though – the joy escapes from Cinnamon's lips to mine. I try to hide it with the toast, but Cinnamon's grin just widens.

Mom watches one more time – obviously ensuring – me eating her bangers, and forms the words "Thanks" with her mouth.

No hoper.

"Cinnamon, you're weird."

"I know. So are you. But at least now you have buttered your bread."

Ha ha ha. A nice little flashback of my morning stupidity waves in front of my eyes. Mom scowls, not getting it.

"Just a little inside joke", I clarify quickly.

"So you're having secrets already? How fun!" When she stands up to fill the water can, I stick two fingers inside my mouth to show how yuckily reconsider word choice she spoke. Cinnamon gives an unsure smile, not deciding unable to decide would flow better whether it's approriate to laugh behind someone else's mother's back. It's funny. Even though I'd speak my Mom down to some of my friends, I'd go bonkers if the friend actually agreed with me. Cinnamon seems to think the same.

"Your middle name is Elizabeth, right?" she says suddenly.

"Yeah. Because of that lipstick." I glance quickly at Mom to see how she reacts, but she doesn't seem to notice.

"Then your initials are S. E. C."

"So...?" She's totally beating around the bush.

"Sec means 'dry'. In French", Cinnamon announces and keeps on eating.

"And?"

"Nothing. I finished."

I'm having a hard time deciding whether this was a poor try to start a conversation or is Cinnamon just proving her ability to sink under the surface whenever and wherever.

I think I'll go with the latter.


Sorry for taking so long to critique this.

Ok, quite good. Though I think you could have taken the chance to develop your character here - for example, tell me why she's a vegetarian, and write more about her feelings to Cinnamon's response to her eating habits.

Also, Cinnamon was OOC here a bit. Up to know, I was sure she was a rasther kind, friendly girl - and she acts outright bitchy here, I'm sorry to say. Just seemed a bit strange.

And also, I found it rather strange that Satin's Mum was so willing to overlook her daughter's eating convictions and habits. I mean, she may hae tried to convicne her to eat meat, but openly reprimand her for it? That seemed rather far-fetched.

Looking forward to some more, though - and a proper plot? Very Happy

_________________
~Memory is a child walking along a seashore. You can never tell what small pebble it will pick up and store away among its treasured things~

Away until August 31st (possibly longer)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
CastlesInTheSky   View This User's Portfolio
Novelist

84
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 13
Joined: 25 Jul 2008
Posts: 292
Reviews: 84
Country: England
381 Points

PostPosted: Wed Aug 06, 2008 11:08 am    Post subject: Re: Bubbling, chapter 9 Reply with quote

Demeter wrote:
Mom has made bangers and mash.


That's an English meal, not an Australian one, right? Why not research Australian food? I just looked it up, and the results show they do things like:
-cornbread with sweet potato
-pepper crusted lamb with plum chutney
-potato salad Australian style (This would be a good one to use for this meal, because then it would show the reader that you ARE aware of the country that the story's set in.)
Those other dishes I mentioned, just use them for other mealtimes in the house, yeah? Laughing

Quote:
Reckon Cinnamon's first "city meal" must be something else than burgers or barbie.


Reckon?? Rethink verb choice. Or completely rephrase sentence.

Quote:
Mom looks still annoyed, but that's totally in vain, I tell you.

Totally seems out of place with the more old-fashioned phrase 'in vain'. Try putting : Mom still looks annoyed, but that's obviously in vain.

Quote:
"Reckon, Mrs Chevrol... Ebony."

Again, take out the word reckon. Doesn't make sense.

Quote:
"Give it away, Satin. You have eaten meat before."

Do you mean Give it up?

Quote:
Reckon she said that just for my bad.

Huh?

Quote:
Mom makes a weird noise.

Think of a better description. Like, Mom grunted , or Mom sucked her teeth.

Quote:
"Don't you talk that way about Mrs Hamdram, young lady", she says. "You know she's been my good mate..."

Mate? 2 things wrong with that:

1) Mate is an English colloquialism. Laughing
2) Would a grown woman who speaks as poshly as Satin's Mom does call someone her good mate? I think not. Instead, say 'my close friend'.

Quote:
"Sorry to interrupt your... interesting conversation", Cinnamon cuts me off. "Satin, I admire your try to change the topic, but I won't let you away with it. Just eat the meat and stop whinging. Or eat some bread, then."

This was a bit of a weird thing to say, but if you want to keep it in, change the grammar: "Sorry to interrupt your...interesting conversation," says Cinnamon, cutting me off. "Satin, I admire your trying to change the topic, but I won't let you get away with it. Just eat the meat and stop whinging. Or eat some bread, then."

Quote:
After swallowing, I start to chew an enourmous piece of toast.

Enourmous? It's spelt : Enormous. Laughing

Quote:
Cinnamon keeps staring at the plate, but even a stupid one

I think you mean: But even an idiot / but even someone stupid


[b]I liked this ninth chapter, but something really needs to happen.

Maybe we find out a haunting secret about Cinnamon's past, which has made her like she is?
Or an accident happens and Satin realises how much closer she has grown to Cinnamon?
Something like that to make the reader keep reading.

The reason I haven't reviewed your chapters since my review of Chapter 4 is because there was nothing, gramatically speaking, that wasn't covered by the other critiquers. I really liked Chapter 5. Keep Writing.

Sarah

_________________
Dreams are the eraser dust I blow off my page.
They fade into the emptiness, another dark gray day.
Dreams are only memories of the plans I had back then.
Dreams are eraser dust and now I use a pen.
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website MSN Messenger
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on June 12, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
This thread was created on June 12, 2008

Graphics By Bobo | YWS Sword & Shield Logo by Bobo
Bartemius says, A memorandum isn't written to inform the receiver, but to protect the writer. - Dean Acheson
Contact | Memberlist | Copyright Policy | YWS Store | Site Map
Facebook |  Goodreads |  Live Journal |  MySpace |  Wikipedia

© 2004 - 2008 The Young Writers Society