Stop The Scrolling Header | Enable the Scrolling Header

Firefox 3

News:  

What Are You Reading?

Attention College Students!
Username:    Password:      Log me on automatically each visit    
DATAFILE. 01 COMIC....3
DATAFILE. 01 COMIC....3

by Lord Anzius in Art & Photography
Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction

This thread was created on May 16, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
Digg It Del.icio.us


Poptart
Topic ID: 30327
View previous topic :: View next topic  
Author Message
Monki   View This User's Portfolio
loves you!
Novelist

87
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 29 Nov 2007
Posts: 495
Reviews: 87
Country: Somewhere Between Adulthood and Childhood
300 Points

PostPosted: Sat May 17, 2008 3:20 am    Post subject: Poptart Reply with quote

Prologue:

Jealousy. It rages inside of me. I feel that if people look me in the eyes, they can see a fire burning.

I take out my iPod and turn it to the angriest-sounding song on it. It doesn't really pertain to my situation. And it really doesn't make me feel better either. I want to put myself through pain. I don't want to be happy. I know I don't deserve the angst, the torture, the depression. But I can't put anyone else through it. The only person I can torture... is myself.

I fall asleep listening to angry songs. Nightmares lurk around every metaphorical corner of my mind. I have no where to hide. I must suffer until morning.

One:

I had no idea that waking up could actually be a good thing. Most times, I never want to wake up, but last night, the nightmares kept coming, one after another.

I dread dragging myself out of that bed. I should probably just stay home. School will just consist of more suffering. But do I really have a say in the matter? No, not really. Unfortunately, school isn't optional.

Eating has become nothing more than a chore to me anymore. Food used to be my life. I worshipped and prayed to it. It made me feel good when I was eating it, but guilty afterwards. But no matter what, it was there for me, and I knew that.

I walk into the kitchen and see Mom taking out the milk.

"Morning," I mutter wearily.

"Morning sunshine!" she shouts to me. Mom's never been a fan of speaking with her 'inside voice'.

"Ow," I reply. "Ever heard of inside voices?"

She apparently hears the annoyance in my voice. "What's your problem?" she snaps back at me.

"You," I lie. Sometimes, I have to be harsh with her so that she understands that I don't feel like arguing.

She sighs and trots back upstairs to her room. I know she doesn't mean to be so overbearing, but she should know that I'm easily annoyed.

Since I sleep in the clothes that I'm going to wear the next day, I'm already dressed, so I grab a poptart, yell upstairs to Mom, and walk out the door, binder in hand.

Everyday, I walk to my bus stop, sit on the huge rock in the grass, and eat my poptart, silently watching what everyone is doing. Kind of creepy, but it's interesting. I've been told that I'd make a really good anthropologist. Such a big, scary sounding name for a person who studies the behavior of people.

Anyway, every now and again, the bus comes early, and we're not allowed to take food on the bus, so I throw the poptart in the road so I can watch the bus run it over. But today, I've come to realize that I'm kind of like that poor, helpless poptart. Alone, cold, left there for someone to come along and pick up the pieces of me.

Except, no one comes.

Two:

And there he is again, where he always is; Sitting there in his usual seat with all of his friends around him. Mocking me. Silently mocking me. All of them.

Do I dare sit back there?

Do I dare to even look back there?

No.

I sit down in the fourth seat from the front and lecture myself about what an idiot I am. God, I'm such an idiot.

As the bus starts moving, I take out my notebook and doodle little hearts all over the page with his name inside each one. Wow. I must be feeling bold today. I've just wasted a whole piece of paper. And they call me a tree-hugger. How wrong they are! But I'm sure that trees would like to take a stab at me now. I have betrayed them.

I laugh at myself every few minutes. I mean, how stupid of me to even think that I have a fighting chance with him. Because seriously, it's him. The same him that most girls want to be with. That same exact him who has dated every cheerleader on the squad and is currently dating his way through the girl's soccer team. Which reminds me that I should really try out for soccer this week...

The bus insists on hopping up and down, ruining my perfect hearts in the process. I decide to surrender my efforts. We're almost at school anyway.

We file off of the bus, one by one. I'm the fifth person to get off. I walk slowly toward the doors of the school. Maybe he'll catch up to me and walk next to me. Maybe we'll strike up a conversation. Maybe there will be a part of that conversation where he confesses his undying love for me--'accidentally' of course.

Okay, forget it. After about two seconds of walking slowly, he's right behind me, so I break into a run because I am a stupid, cowardly loser. I'm the first person to reach the doors. I open them and the cool air rushes through my frizzy hair.

I walk in and the doors slam right in his face.

Crap! That was really stupid.

"Are you okay?" I ask him as he walks in, holding his face--that beautiful, flawless face.

"Yeah, I'm fine," he answers.

"Yes you are," I agree.

"Huh?" he questions me.

"Oh, um... I'm glad you're okay. See you around. Bye." Well, if sounding like a babbling idiot was my goal, I totally aced it. I really need to work on my people skills.

I run up the stairs to get to English. I guess I was running so fast that I failed to see the garbage can in the middle of the hallway. I've got to remember that running in the hallway isn't cool. It just make you seem like an eager nerd, ready to learn. I look like "Let's learn!" is my motto. It might as well be written on my shirt: "Let's learn, everybody!"

I look around to make sure that no one saw my second act of stupidity today. Wow, I'm not even in first period yet and chances are I've broken Shawn's nose-or face-and ran into a garbage can. That's got to be a new world record.

I slowly walk around the garbage can. It could be planning another sneak attack! I reach homeroom and open the door. Of course, the eager nerd is the first to get to class. Yeah, I'm talking about me. I sit down in the empty classroom.

Three:

It's almost 7:15. The final bell is about to ring, telling us that we should be in class, and if we're not, we're marked absent. Not that the teachers care. Oh, well. One less unruly adolescent to babysit.

Mr. Moo walks in. Well, that's what I call him. I give all of my teachers secret nicknames that no one else knows about, except my best friend Amber. She thinks it's weird, but she calls them by their secret names too.

I call him Mr. Moo, obviously, because of the size of him. I mean, the size of his arm is like, the size of my whole body. See, now wouldn't you call him Mr. Moo too? That is, if you were smart enough to make up a super cool name like that. Because it takes a real genius to come up with a name like Mr. Moo.

He quickly takes attendance. I know he doesn't want to be here, but he really doesn't need to say, "Come on! Just say here if you're here. I really don't want to be here." Seriously. Who does that?

He gives us an assignment to do from the text book and puts the answers up on the projector. "Now, once you finish the assignment, you can check your work with this." He points to the answers projected on the board and gives us this weird smile and winks.

No one opens the text books. We hurriedly copy down the answers so that we can have the rest of the period to do homework for other classes that were supposed to be done last night, talk amongst ourselves (loudly), or just do whatever we want.

I have all my homework done. We didn't really have any last night except to memorize the whole Periodic Table of the Elements, read all of chapter fifteen for Geometry and do the review at the end, and create abstract art out of garbage. I loved that one. I used soda cans, Starburst candy wrappers, and pretty much anything I found in the garbage can in my room.

I don't have any friends in this class, so I kind of just keep to myself. I work on some drawings in my sketch book. I'm not actually good, but I love it. Right now, I'm working on drawing a gerbil eating a dog. Don't ask me how that's possible because I really can't tell you.

The bell finally rings. I jump up from my seat. I'm so excited to see Amber and tell her about my little mishap with Shawn. She'll be so proud of me for actually saying something to him. It was a sad excuse for a conversation, but it was still a conversation.

Four:

"Amber, Amber, Amber, Amber, Amber, Am-!" I scream her name until she interrupts me.

"What?" she asks me. She seems annoyed. I wonder why.

"I talked to him!" I tell her. "And I think he likes me!"

"Who him?! Him-him?" she asks. This conversation really starts to get confusing.

"Yeah!" I exclaim.

"No!" she argues.

"Yep! I think I broke his nose or his face or something, but I talked to him!" I'm in hysterics here.

She slaps me. "You idiot! You can't break a guys face and expect him to suddenly realize that he likes you!"

She's got a point. "You might be right." I ponder this while she explodes at me.

"Might? Might?! Of course I'm right!" she yells at me.

"Okay, okay, you're right. Don't hurt me. I didn't know what to think," I defend myself.

"You better just hope he forgets that this happened," she advises me.

We begin to walk to our next class together.

She finally speaks. "Do you want to just skip the rest of today? I really don't feel like being here. We can go to my house or something and figure out how we're gonna fix you."

"Fix me?" I question her.

"Yes. You've got to admit, you need fixing. If you want Shawn to like you, you're going to need some professional help. And that's where I come in."

Well, I would say kudos to you, but you've already kudos-ed yourself enough, wouldn't you say? I think to myself.

"Fine. But if my mom finds out that I skipped again, she'll murder me. She'll cut off my butt and hang it over the mantle. She'll-" This girl needs to learn some manners. She keeps interrupting me in the middle of my babbling and ranting and such. Is that what best friends are for?

"Okay, let's go," she interrupts me.

We walk out the double doors at the other end of the school and head to her car. Lucky freakin' duck. Sometimes I forget that she's a year older than me. She can drive and I can't. A friend with benefits. Hey! Not like that! I know what you're thinking! Goodness, people and their sick minds these days...


_________________
"I LOVE YOU, MELISSA!!!!!" -my best friends, Sarah and Brittany, yelling to me in the hallway and getting weird looks from people thinking we're lesbians when we're the farthest thing from it


Last edited by Monki on Tue Jun 10, 2008 5:23 pm; edited 8 times in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
Azila   View This User's Portfolio
October... it's Vegetarian Awareness Month!
Speaker of the Forum

501
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 13
Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 967
Reviews: 501
Country: The Valley of the Wind
333 Points

PostPosted: Sat May 17, 2008 2:59 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Nitpicks

Quote:
I turned on my iPod and turned it to the angriest-sounding song I had.
--I don't like the repetition of "turned" in this sentence. Maybe "switched" (either instance) or even "put" (second instance)

Quote:
And it didn't make me feel better either. I wanted to put myself through pain.
--The period after "either" should be a semicolon, methinks.

Quote:
I knew I didn't deserve the angst, the pain, the depression. But, I couldn't put anyone else through the pain.
--I don't like the repetition of "the pain" here. Maybe try using "hurt" or "agony."

Quote:
But, my mom made sure that I ate breakfast before I went to school. Food used to be my life. Food made me feel good when I was eating it, but guilty afterwards. But, I didn't care.
--You say "but" a lot in this passage here. Maybe the one before "guilty" could be "then"?

Quote:
The food didn't care. It was there for me.
--I don't understand what you're trying to say here... do you mean "it WASN'T there for me?"

Quote:
"GOOD MORNING!!!" she yells to me.
--Rather than using all caps, i suggest using italics.

Quote:
"What's YOUR problem?" she snaps back at me.
--Same here; italics, not caps.

Quote:
Except, no one comes. I am a poptart.
--I think "except no one comes." would make such a beautiful last line. Saying "I am a poptart" is just repetition of what you said before. It feels out of place and -- frankly -- I don't like it as much as "except no one comes." If you really like it, though, at least put it on its own line to separate these two sentences.
___________________________

Overall Impressions


Punctuation
You seem to think that if "but" is a the first word of a sentence, you need to put a comma after it -- but that actually isn't true. Here are some examples:
Quote:
But, I couldn't put anyone else through the pain.
Quote:
But, my mom made sure that I ate breakfast before I went to school.
Quote:
But, I didn't care.
Those are just a few... there are more. You really don't need that comma and it actually messes up the flow, in my opinion.


Tense
This piece switches tense! Surprised The beginning part is in past, but then it changes to present for the end. Here's where it changes:
Quote:
I walked into the kitchen and saw Mom taking out the milk.

"Morning," I muttered.

"GOOD MORNING!!!" she yells to me.

"Ow. Could you maybe not yell when I first wake up?" I complain.
The first two sentences are in past tense ("walked," "saw," "muttered") and the second two are in present ("yells," "complain"). Everything before now is in past and everything after it is in present. Wink


Plot
This piece is interesting. But there isn't much originality about it. It's pretty much just about some depressed person (I assume a teenager) who finds a depressing image to compare themself to. We don't even know why he/she (I assume it's a girl, for some reason) is depressed. A little more insight into his/her past would be nice, I think.


Please don't take this crit too harshly! I'm not trying to be mean... honest!

PM me if I was unclear about anything.

Hope this helps.
~Azila~

_________________
Want a critique?

"Never bolt your door with a boiled carrot." -Irish proverb. (sounds best if you read it with an Irish brogue)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Icaruss   View This User's Portfolio
Disgustingly Honest.
Novelist

112
Gender: Gender:Male
Age: 17
Joined: 14 Sep 2005
Posts: 475
Reviews: 112
Country: Peru.
354 Points

PostPosted: Sat May 17, 2008 4:38 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Oh, God. I'm going to try to be honest here without trying to be mean or unkind. I always feel guilty about writing these kinds of reviews because, after all, we really are basically the same person. We're just people on the Internet. I mean, what makes me qualified to say what's good or what's bad? What gives me the authority? That's not to say that I can't say something is bad unless everything I write is fantastic. I always get angry when I tell somebody, I go: "That was a terrible book/movie/porno". And they'll go: "You couldn't have done it better." When I get that kind of talk, I'm always thinking: "Well, it's still a piece of junk."

What I mean is that I want you to question what I say, I want you to take my advice or to not take my advice, I want you to do whatever you want. That being said, I thought this was bad. It's like you talk about what the character is feeling as if it were new, and insightful, and authentic, when it really is not. It's like you took the lyrics to a My Chemical Romance song, added a little Simple Plan to the mix, and threw in the angryness of an old Papa Roach song just for good measure. Nothing of what you say is deep or even original. I mean, I wanted to beat the heck out of your character. Really. He isn't sad, he isn't angry. I mean, he isn't even a character. Your guy is woe itself. I wanted to slap him around and tell him: "Boo-hoo. Stop crying!"

The fact that, as Azila mentioned, you don't even tell us why he is feeling this way further exemplifies the fact that he is one-dimensional. He is starts out being angry, he is angry, he'll be angry in the future. Like I said, he isn't Tom or John or Xerxes, he is woe itself. And that just makes me sigh. Is he a man or a woman, by the way? Not that it would matter anyways. You see what I'm saying?

Random Thought #129: Don't use all caps. It looks terrible. Harry Potter used to do it, and when the fifth book came out it had more big letters than little letters, I just dropped the series. I will watch the movie, though. But seriously, it just looks amateurish (which we all are, of course) and plain ugly.

But enough about the character. Let's talk about the way you write. It's not particularly bad. I mean, most people that come here are good enough writers. But does it sound good? Does it read easily? Halfway through the iPod paragraph ("I can't make anyone else feel my pain"), I rolled my eyes and scrolled down to see how much more I had to endure. I mean, the things you talk about, they just make me want to gouge my eyes out, because it's like you found an EmoBot.com website and have him tell you what to say. It lacks real emotion because it feels rehearsed. It lacks real emotion because it's so generic. It lacks real emotion because your character was one step away from being the one singing those songs he was listening to and being the one trashed by the Rolling Stone magazine.

Also: the opening line made me laugh. The thing about the fire, I mean. "Licking up everything"? Heh. Licking? Heh. Other things fire does that sound more... less funny: consumes, etc. Note how I ran out of things to say right after consumes. Boy, do I feel like an idiot.

OK, and the poptart thing? The metaphor that gives the title to your piece, the thing that's supposed to tie it up all together? It's silly. You're comparing yourself to pastry. Pastry. Paaaaaah-iiiis-try. It just falls flat. Yeah, I know. Your soul is just like the poptart. It's all broken and shattered. Right. And by the way, wouldn't the bus just squash the poptart flat, rather than break it apart? Hurm.

Random Thought #209: Don't put in names of songs. It suggests that we have to come in with previous knowledge, or having listened to the song. When we haven't, it just nags us. It's OK to put it as a throwaway reference, just like you would do a movie. But to put it in as an example of how rotten your character feels is just irresponsible. And I refuse to download the song. Man, that kind of music makes me want to stick an axe into the back of my neck.

So, what I suggest is for you to save this piece of writing under a file called: "No-Nos." You look at it and see where you went wrong. And then you write about things that you've actually felt, things that have actually happened to you. Because you may think you've felt the things this character is feeling, but you haven't. No-one really has. Not like that.

Heh. Look at me trying to tell you what you've felt and what you haven't. Don't worry, I slapped myself around for you.


Moderator: Please keep all curse words to literature only - Thanks.

_________________
All you little girls, settin' out that line,
I can make love to you, woman, in five seconds time.
Ain't that a man?


Last edited by Icaruss on Sat May 17, 2008 5:10 pm; edited 1 time in total
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message MSN Messenger
Monki   View This User's Portfolio
loves you!
Novelist

87
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 29 Nov 2007
Posts: 495
Reviews: 87
Country: Somewhere Between Adulthood and Childhood
300 Points

PostPosted: Sat May 17, 2008 4:56 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Lmao. Thank you both for the review. Truthfully, after reading your review Icaruss, I realized my stupidity... I just kind of wrote what I felt. I didn't mean to really extend on it. It was just kind of... on a whim really. Thanks for helping me come to the realization that this is crap... I mean, I don't know anyone who would like this. At first, I did. But, I read your review, and I was like, "Well, Icaruss makes good points. About the whole poptart thing, not putting the name of the song (I kept questioning myself about putting the name of a song when I was writing this, too), etc..." I guess I was just trying to keep the reader wondering about everything until later on in the story... So, I take it that it didn't work. Lol.

Thanks again for the review, both of you.

_________________
"I LOVE YOU, MELISSA!!!!!" -my best friends, Sarah and Brittany, yelling to me in the hallway and getting weird looks from people thinking we're lesbians when we're the farthest thing from it
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
Jellybee   View This User's Portfolio
Junior Writer

6
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 16
Joined: 17 May 2008
Posts: 15
Reviews: 6
Country: Canada-Québec!
300 Points

PostPosted: Sat May 17, 2008 11:35 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I'm fine you saw the whole, well, the whole point of your story Monki. I am not very used to read in English so I thought first when I read your text that this "licking up" was weird- but I just thought, it's the normal way of writing of these English...and I tried to read without bias against the Hamlet's language- even if I think that the vocabulary is too poor, or mine is!-

When I finish reading your text, I just thought: It was something in her head,and now it's just something indefinable. I guess that the pop-tart thing appeared in your head in a flash. Please, 'cause if no, there are some reason why sugar is bad. I mean, too much pop-tarts kill the pop-tarts.

I wait your next text, because I'm sure that you have the potential, and except this one , the ideas for write a good thing. A better.

_________________
No one lies to everybody. Everybody lies to one. Pline The Young_
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message MSN Messenger
Monki   View This User's Portfolio
loves you!
Novelist

87
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 29 Nov 2007
Posts: 495
Reviews: 87
Country: Somewhere Between Adulthood and Childhood
300 Points

PostPosted: Sun May 18, 2008 12:08 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

Thank you, JellyBee! I appreciate your post. If you would ever like me to read any of your text, please feel free to PM me. Smile

_________________
"I LOVE YOU, MELISSA!!!!!" -my best friends, Sarah and Brittany, yelling to me in the hallway and getting weird looks from people thinking we're lesbians when we're the farthest thing from it
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
Monki   View This User's Portfolio
loves you!
Novelist

87
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 29 Nov 2007
Posts: 495
Reviews: 87
Country: Somewhere Between Adulthood and Childhood
300 Points

PostPosted: Sun May 18, 2008 2:59 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hey, Azila! I just read your critique again. I guess I kind of forgot to reply to yours.

No, that's actually not harsh at all compared to other critiques I've gotten. ^ ^

I'm about to edit this using your suggestions, so if you want, I can PM you once I edit it and I'll probably add some more, too.

Thanks!

_________________
"I LOVE YOU, MELISSA!!!!!" -my best friends, Sarah and Brittany, yelling to me in the hallway and getting weird looks from people thinking we're lesbians when we're the farthest thing from it
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message AIM Address
Azila   View This User's Portfolio
October... it's Vegetarian Awareness Month!
Speaker of the Forum

501
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 13
Joined: 23 Jul 2007
Posts: 967
Reviews: 501
Country: The Valley of the Wind
333 Points

PostPosted: Sun May 18, 2008 4:59 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Monki wrote:
I'm about to edit this using your suggestions, so if you want, I can PM you once I edit it and I'll probably add some more, too.
Sure, Monki! PM me once you've edited and I'll come back and (if you've edited a lot) give you another review. That is to say, I might not review if all you've done is a few sentence structure things, lol.

Anyway, so definitely PM me! I'll be sure to come back and take another look for ya. Wink

~Azila~

_________________
Want a critique?

"Never bolt your door with a boiled carrot." -Irish proverb. (sounds best if you read it with an Irish brogue)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Demeter   View This User's Portfolio
Five stars!
Speaker of the Forum

253
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 15
Joined: 02 May 2008
Posts: 744
Reviews: 253
Country: Finland
300 Points

PostPosted: Tue Jun 10, 2008 6:22 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Hey, Monki! Here I am!

Quote:
And it really doesn't make me feel better either.


A comma after "better".


Quote:
Mom's never been a fan of speaking with her 'inside voice'.

"Ow," I reply. "Ever heard of inside voices?"


Quote:
It just make you seem like an eager nerd, ready to learn. I look like "Let's learn!" is my motto. It might as well be written on my shirt: "Let's learn, everybody!"


Quote:
I call him Mr. Moo, obviously, because of the size of him. I mean, the size of his arm is like, the size of my whole body. See, now wouldn't you call him Mr. Moo too? That is, if you were smart enough to make up a super cool name like that. Because it takes a real genius to come up with a name like Mr. Moo.


All of these parts are funny, but be careful – they're also repetitive.


Quote:
I throw the poptart in the road so I can watch the bus run it over.


Good job! But I'd suggest comma between "road" and "so".


Quote:
the girl's soccer team


The girls'.


Quote:
"Are you okay?" I ask him as he walks in, holding his face--that beautiful, flawless face.

"Yeah, I'm fine," he answers.

"Yes you are," I agree.


That's funny Wink


Quote:
"Huh?" he questions me.


Words after "Huh?" are unnecessary.


Quote:
"Who him?! Him-him?"


Funny, again!


Quote:
"You might be right."


Might? Not may?


So, I think this is a good story, overall. There aren't really typos or any other grammar errors, either. I like the title, too. There are funny bits, which is great. You could use more description – what do they look like, how do they talk and walk, etc. I'm also disturbed that by chapter four, we don't know the MC's name. Or maybe that's the point?

Maybe that's only because the chapters are so short, but I felt like there's something missing. It'll probably get better in the fifth chapter, though Wink PM me when it's up, will you?


See you around!
Demeter xx

_________________
So how are we gonna ditch the dodo?
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Snoink   View This User's Portfolio
Snuggly
Writer of Legend

2105
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 20
Joined: 02 Apr 2005
Posts: 8437
Reviews: 2105
Country: USA
546 Points

PostPosted: Tue Jun 10, 2008 6:44 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

It sounds like you're working on this still, so I guess I'll critique! Razz

PROLOGUE

It sucks. Get rid of it.

CHAPTER 1

The argument between the mom and the narrator sounds false. This is the main drama in your chapter... so dramatize it! This will help us get into the story better by giving us a conflict we can relate to and sympathize with.

Also, the poptart thing is lame. It reminds me of my younger writing career... I think I was fourteen as well Wink ... when I wrote this suicide scene where there was this one character who decided she wanted to kill herself because of a zucchini. I think it was something along the lines of, "This zucchini symbolizes my life and OMG, I WANT TO DIE." Yeah. It was really lame. And you don't want lame writing! So either have your character realize how lame she is being or get rid of it.

CHAPTER 2

The self-hate and woe this character is feeling is almost unbearable. Is life really that bad? Nobody's noticing her... and she's not really making an effort to be noticed. So what's the problem?

Also, by saying that she's not good enough for the guy, that's guaranteeing that you're going to hook them together in the next chapter or something. Very predictable, which is bad. Show why they wouldn't go together. A good example on YWS to see this in action is this: Crazy Little Thing I by Arieda. So read it, if you like it, star it, and learn from it. Smile

CHAPTER 3

Uh... what is the point of this chapter?

There was only one good thing about this chapter:

"...and create abstract art out of garbage. I loved that one. I used soda cans, Starburst candy wrappers, and pretty much anything I found in the garbage can in my room."

This seems true.

CHAPTER 4

WAIT. She is awkward and weird with Shawn and then she talks to her friend and tells her that Shawn may possibly like her? Um... what just happened? I never considered that he even liked her for a second, and I didn't think that she thought that he might possibly like her. Maybe you can have her talk about this in chapter 3?

So... yay! More direction? Razz

_________________
Leopluridon '08: He Will Show Us The Way!

"So, Obama calls McCain erratic. Well, I call Obama a squirrel." -- Rush Limbaugh
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message Visit poster's website AIM Address Yahoo Messenger MSN Messenger
Periwinkle   View This User's Portfolio
jazz hands!
Novelist

99
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 15
Joined: 01 Mar 2008
Posts: 267
Reviews: 99
Country: Crayola Crayon Box
324 Points

PostPosted: Tue Jun 10, 2008 7:21 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

I. NITPICKS
Quote:
Jealousy. It rages inside of me. I feel that if people look me in the eyes, they can see a fire burning.


You start out with something promising here but you don’t deliver. You should really expand on this. It’s really bland and not that much of a great hook.


Quote:
I take out my iPod and turn it to the angriest-sounding song on it. It doesn't really pertain to my situation [combine this with the next sentence]. And it really doesn't make me feel better either. I want to put myself through pain. I don't want to be happy. I know I don't deserve the angst, the torture, the depression. But I can't put anyone else through it. The only person I can torture... is myself.



Quote:
I fall asleep listening to angry songs. Nightmares lurk around every metaphorical corner of my mind. I have no where to hide. I must suffer until morning.



Quote:
I had no idea that waking up could actually be a good thing. Most times, I never want to wake up, but last night, the nightmares kept coming, one after another.


Should be “Most times I don’t want to wake up, but last night the nightmares kept coming one after another.

Quote:
I dread dragging myself out of that bed [But didn‘t she want to wake up]. I should probably just stay home. School will just consist of more suffering. But do I really have a say in the matter? No, not really. Unfortunately, school isn't optional.


Quote:
Eating has become nothing more than a chore to me anymore [should be “now“]. Food used to be my life. I worshipped and prayed to it. It made me feel good when I was eating it, but guilty afterwards. But no matter what, it was there for me, and I knew that.


Quote:
I walk into the kitchen and see Mom taking out the milk.


Oh is this a holy milk? I’m kidding, best said as “carton of milk” or “jug of milk”


Quote:
She apparently hears the annoyance in my voice. "What's your problem?" she snaps back at me.


Why is she snapping now?

Quote:
"You," I lie. Sometimes, I have to be harsh with her so that she understands that I don't feel like arguing.


Quote:
Since I sleep in the clothes that I'm going to wear the next day, I'm already dressed, so I grab a poptart , yell upstairs to Mom [Awkward! Change this - it sounds like she’s just yelling at her mom not saying “goodbye”] , and walk out the door, binder in hand.




Quote:
And there he is again, where he always is; [Should be a dash and “sitting shouldn’t be capitalized] Sitting there in his usual seat with all of his friends around him. Mocking me. Silently mocking me. All of them.


Quote:
I sit down in the fourth seat from the front and lecture myself about what an idiot I am. God, I'm such an idiot.


What has she done? She just seems paranoid to me…

Quote:
As the bus starts moving, I take out my notebook and doodle little hearts all over the page with his name inside each one. Wow. I must be feeling bold today. I've just wasted a whole piece of paper. And they call me a tree-hugger. How wrong they are! But [Try not to start out with “but” or “and” - this sentence is find without either] I'm sure that trees would like to take a stab at me now. I have betrayed them.


Quote:
I laugh at myself every few minutes. I mean, how stupid of me to even think that I have a fighting chance with him. Because seriously , it's him. The same him that most girls want to be with. That same exact him who has dated every cheerleader on the squad and is currently dating his way through the girl's soccer team. Which reminds me that I should really try out for soccer this week…



Quote:
I run up the stairs to get to English. I guess I was running so fast that I fail to see the garbage can in the middle of the hallway. I've got to remember that running in the hallway isn't cool. It just make you seem like an eager nerd, ready to learn. I look like "Let's learn!" is my motto. It might as well be written on my shirt: "Let's learn, everybody!"





Quote:
It's almost 7:15. The final bell is about to ring, telling us that we should be in class, and if we're not, we're marked absent. Not that the teachers care. Oh, well. One less unruly adolescent to babysit.[I think this should be “Not that the teachers care or anything - it‘s just one less unruly adolescent to babysit.


Quote:
Mr. Moo walks in. Well, that's what I call him. I give all of my teachers secret nicknames that no one else knows about, except my best friend Amber [secrets imply that no one knows just say: “I give all my teachers secret nicknames that only my best friend, Amber, and I know.”]. She thinks it's weird, but she calls them by their secret names too.


Quote:
I call him Mr. Moo, obviously, because of the size of him. I mean, the size of his arm is like, the size of my whole body. See, now wouldn't you call him Mr. Moo too? That is, if you were smart enough to make up a super cool name like that. Because it takes a real genius to come up with a name like Mr. Moo.


I don’t get the nickname…cows are really that big…



Quote:
No one opens the text books. We hurriedly copy down the answers so that we can have the rest of the period to do homework for other classes that were supposed to be done last night [homework implies that it was supposed to be completed the other night], talk amongst ourselves (loudly), or just do whatever we want.


Quote:
I have all my homework done. We didn't really have any last night except to memorize the whole Periodic Table of the Elements, read all of chapter fifteen for Geometry and do the review at the end, and create abstract art out of garbage. I loved that one. I used soda cans, Starburst candy wrappers, and pretty much anything I found in the garbage can in my room.
I don't have any friends in this class, so I kind of just keep to myself. I work on some drawings in my sketch book. I'm not actually good, but I love it. Right now, I'm working on drawing a gerbil eating a dog. Don't ask me how that's possible because I really can't tell you.


Odd…she never brought this in? Only her binder and a poptart…


Quote:
"I talked to him!" I tell her. "And I think he likes me!"

Laughing



Quote:
"Might? Might?! Of course I'm right!" she yells at me.


Why is she yelling?


II. TEENAGE ANGSTANGSTANGST

Okay, you present us with a character and at first she’s angry and jealous and so-angry-I-just-have-to-turn-on-some-angry-screaming-music girl. You never tell us why she’s angry and jealous, you just have her go to sleep on and on to the next chapter where she’s annoyed.

Your character isn’t relatable at all. She’s annoying and for no apparent reason other than I’m-a-teenager-and-I-have-fluctuating-hormones-so-I’m-angry. Don’t let your teenaged characters fall into this trap. It’s not a good characteristic in a character - let alone the MC.
Okay, so then you move on to the next point where she has a crush on the most popular guy in school who can get any girl he wants just because. She slams a door in his face, runs away, and she’s more bothered by the fact that she ran into a trash can and could have possibly embarrassed herself? It makes no sense really. She seems forced…like she’s a marionette and your puppeting her around just because it’s convenient to her plot. Give your character something solid - she’s to wishy-washy right now and her problems are nothing that I can relate to nor care about.

Another thing is…your character seems paranoid to me especially here:

Quote:
And there he is again, where he always is; Sitting there in his usual seat with all of his friends around him. Mocking me. Silently mocking me. All of them.


It seems like she’s making up her own problems and intensifying them rather dealing with real problems that are thrown at her. She’s assuming that they’re all mocking her and later she’s assuming that everyone’s making fun of her over silly things (I.e. running into a trash can, getting to class early, etc.)


III. SENTENCE STRUCTURE.

Your sentence structure irked me. You mostly used the same, short choppy sentences over and over again which isn’t good for flow or variation…things that keep the reader immersed and focused on the story rather than your writing skills. Just fix this by mixing your sentences up .Combine them, cut some out, etc. Do whatever!

IV. OVERALL IMPRESSION

I thought this piece was okay and only okay. It lacks sensory language or imagery which will make your story much better and all the reader to better see and imagine. Set the scene! I think this needs some more work and it will be pretty good - just revamp your character and think about the way you write and the way it flows and how well it reads. PM me if you have questions or anything.

_________________
Maybe you should kiss someone nice or lick a rock, or both - Regina Spektor
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
patience_isnt   View This User's Portfolio
Senior Writer

26
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 14
Joined: 10 Jun 2008
Posts: 102
Reviews: 26
Country: Canada
300 Points

PostPosted: Tue Jun 10, 2008 8:05 pm    Post subject: Reply with quote

Alright, here comes some critique-ing, so don't be offended by anything I say. It sounds like you're still working on it, so all this junk that I'm telling you to change or not to change may help in the long run.

I don't really like the prologue. I think you should either get rid of it all together, or change it derastically.

The first chapter was alright, but it could use some minor tweaking too. The fight between the mother and narrator sounds... Fake? I can't find better vocabulary to discribe what I think of it. I think you should make the daughter a lot more pissy to the mother, while the mother is confused but fights back. Make it more dramatic! Remember, this is the first chapter!

Also, I'm not so sure about the poptart thing. Your character doesn't sound suicidal, so these thoughts aren't very logical. The narrator maybe should throw it at the bus in anger or boredom, or make her kick it across the road. Something to show that she's an average teenage girl who is angry with the way her life is going.

In the second chapter, where the narrator is depressed and is hating herself, I don't understand. No one actually thinks like that. Change it to her day-dreaming about Shawn or something that can make the reader relate. It doesn't have to be anything rated R, but even her planning what she's going to say would make this part so much better.

I think most of the third chapter was unnecassry, unless you have Mr. Moo a big part in another chapter. If not, leave most of that out of there. Except the art class, that was cool.

In the fourth chapter, I didn't understand the conversation between herself and her friend. Shawn didn't like her, and if he does, which I'm guessing later on he will, he didn't show any hint of it. If the narrator is so self-loathing, she wouldn't think Shawn liked her. She would ask her friend for serious help, and her friend would tell her that she would change her.

With these things changed, I'm sure your story will be so much better! I hope I helped and I didn't offend you too much. (But that's what critique-ing is all about, right?)
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
JolieSari55   View This User's Portfolio
Novice

10
Gender: Gender:Female
Age: 19
Joined: 07 May 2008
Posts: 12
Reviews: 10

300 Points

PostPosted: Wed Jun 11, 2008 12:51 am    Post subject: Reply with quote

I really like your main character, however depression prone she may be. She’s got that “I hate the world attitude” which most kids in their teenage years can relate to. However, I think it might be better to give her less of an “I’m going to off myself one day” vibe and more of a sarcastic sass that humors the reader. If she’s always negative then I’m not going to want her to succeed nor am I going to take the time to read the book to see if she will. I think your character would work better if she had more of those chuckle lines and less of those angry thoughts. When writing, I feel as though one’s first goal should be to make the character likable… because, without that, no one will want to read his or her story. With a story like this – the kind with the intense emotions of depression, melancholy- one needs to be careful because everyone deals with these things. You can’t have your character too caught up in misery because then a reader might think “She’s overreacting.”

Anyways, this is all just thought. Thanks for reading! Smile
Back to top
View user's profile Send private message
Display posts from previous:   
This thread was created on May 16, 2008
Post new topic   Reply to topic
   Young Writers Society Forum Index » Other Fiction All times are GMT
Page 1 of 1

 
Jump to:  
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You can attach files in this forum
You can download files in this forum
This thread was created on May 16, 2008

Graphics By Bobo | YWS Sword & Shield Logo by Bobo
Bartemius says, Of those who say nothing, few are silent. - Thomas Neill
Contact | Memberlist | Copyright Policy | YWS Store | Site Map
Facebook |  Goodreads |  Live Journal |  MySpace |  Wikipedia

© 2004 - 2008 The Young Writers Society